Customer Reviews and Ratings

3.0 out of 5 stars

Based on 173 reviews

  • 3.0 out of 5 stars

    Not a good value

    • Written by from McMinnville

    The Red leather is not a dark red as in the picture. The leather is extremely thin and does not clean well. It scratches easy and I am very careful with my iPad. In the future,
    I will purchase something that covers the back of my iPad. This product does not. Overall, I would not pay $69 again for this product. It is not worth the money.

    9 of 12 people found this useful

  • 3.0 out of 5 stars

    Careful with scratches

    • Written by from Montréal

    I really loved my leather cover for the first months - great color, simple, well thought of objet, does what it should do. Yet, I've been annoyed by one thing that slowly became a problem : the suede surface on the inside, that becomes the outside once you open it, roll it up and use it as a stand. Things - dust, crumbs, whatever is on the surface you put it on - tend to cling to it, because it's suede, "hairy". It's difficult to remove little things that get stuck in there. Sure, you can clean the table/desk systematically before putting it on. But I use my ipad a lot, in numerous places. Things tend to get stuck in the suede, no matter how careful you are. And then what happens? They scratch the screen. Very fine surface scratches, sure, nothing overly dramatic, but it's really disapointing. I decided to get an Invisible Shield to protect it - which is a bit absurd : having to protect it from its protective cover... I recommend not taking the leather. The smooth surface of the other cases should avoid that problem.

    9 of 12 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    BEWARE: STAINS

    • Written by from Bloomington

    I loved it in the beginning. Nice color, the deep rich red, one of my favorites then I slowly started to see my case stain red. I have a transparent frosty case on the back and the edges are stained red from this cover. And what is worst is that it takes a long time to happen. So you can't return it. About 2 to 3 months into having this case I noticed the effect, it's cumulative. Now I take it off if I'm wearing white, don't put it on my light sheet covers, or any white thing and definitely keep it out of my more expensive purses. I don't know what else it will stain. Just don't buy it.

    Cheeper is better in this case. Get the polyurethane and get a light color, less chances of color bleeding out.

    I'm really disappointed in apple.

    9 of 10 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    As much use as an apple Smart Cover!

    • Written by from Stockton

    That's what I have replaced 'chocolate fire guard' or 'concrete parachute' with in my daily vernacular. Whilst my daughter was watching a movie using it as a stand she bumped the table lightly, the magnet failed and the ipad slipped off the table. Thank god we have accidental damage insurance...

    10 of 18 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    I do not recommend this product,,,

    • Written by from Tracy

    Red color rubbed off onto my iPad. Fortunately I had the invisible shield on my entire iPad so all I had to do was remove the old shield and install a new one but I had to pay to have it installed. Can't believe Apple would sell this cover. Very disappointed.

    32 of 45 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Detaches too easily

    • Written by from Mountain View

    disconnected from my iPad 4 LTE, and poof! Hit the ground and screen shattered.

    This cover provides ZERO protection for a very expensive device.

    21 of 34 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Case Falling Apart

    • Written by from Des Plaines

    After a few months of use, the case started falling apart in its seams. It appears cheeply glued together. If you can, spend your $70 on another useless thing because sooner or later it will fall apart.

    23 of 29 people found this useful

  • 2.0 out of 5 stars

    Not a great value

    • Written by from Wylie

    i bought this for my new IPad and gave my son a smart case. I have since bought a smart case for me as well. The smart cover magnet that connects to the iPad is not very strong. It is constantly disconnecting. It is very frustrating. It does a good job of putting the IPad to sleep, else, rather worthless.

    18 of 22 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    DO NOT BUY

    • Written by from West Chester

    The product may have been made for a good cause but is bad for white cuffs. It bleeds on to clothes and has spoilt several cuffs of mine.

    28 of 34 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Love it

    • Written by from Tuscola

    Looks good ,color is good, magnet is very strong, very nice Smart Cover

    15 of 21 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Only 4 months. It looks like doo doo

    • Written by from Los angeles

    I will never buy another apple accessory. After market is the way to go. I really loved the red color. I bought a red back cover on amazon. The back cover looks great. The Apple Smart Cover looks terrible. I did not abuse it in any way but it looks funky in some areas. So disappointing,

    20 of 29 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Works well for my needs!

    • Written by from Gloucester

    My intent is to review this smart cover for what it actually is, not for what some thought it was. First off, it's basically a "cosmetic cover", meaning there is protection for your screen, the sleep/wake feature and fold back stand in the broadest sense of the word. What it is not is a protection cover for the front and rear of the iPad. For that, you will need a folio style "case" not a cover!

    I find it so unfair when reviewers state that the cover doesn't do this and doesn't do that and the product was never intended for those uses to begin with. It's unfair for those searching for the right cover or case when the reviews are off base due to what they wanted not what they received.

    I am very pleased with the minimalistic nature of this cover. It keeps the slim profile that I love about my iPad. I have different cases depending on what I'm doing with my ipad. I have this smart cover in both the black and red leather and love both of them. I'm getting ready to receive two new iPad 4th generations for both my husband and myself and I'll be using the red which is currently on my iPad 2 and the hubs will be using the black one. We both have hard shell backs with a magnetic strip that holds the cover behind the ipad very well.

    If you're looking for a smart cover to use mainly as a screen cover with the sleep/wake feature, this cover can't be beat. Just know what you are ordering and judge it for that purpose, please! I have not had a magnate issue for either of my smart covers and the dirt factor has not been an issue either.

    46 of 54 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    LOVE IT

    • Written by from Picayune

    I love my red leather cover. It makes me so happy. I got it for Christmas last year, and it is like new. I don't take it anywhere though so it does not get rough treatment. The magnetic cover works great. Snaps right on.

    10 of 12 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Pretty interesting results!

    • Written by from Cypress

    As a person who is always on the go and fan of red I opted for this cover. Over the year and some months I've had this cover I haven't been disappointed with it. Yes it tends to get dirty, but the interesting thing is in time it started to have that more " old vintage" look that I also love. Alot of my co-workers and friends ask where I got it and are surprised when I say "...it's just an old (PRODUCT)Red case." Definitely better than having one of those book look alike covers that some of people around me have. With a little leather care upkeep the case has survived through all this time and like a fine wine is becoming better with age.

    13 of 15 people found this useful

  • 4.0 out of 5 stars

    Innovative, useful and convenient, no dirt problem here!

    • Written by from Claremont

    I like my smart cover. I was a little unsure initially; I have another case as well to prove that... but I found myself liking the minimalism of the smart cover. I did add a slim polycarbonate case for the back, primarily for grip, but it actually has a metal plate so that the smart cover will stay folded back. My other, larger case, I use when I'm taking my iPad somewhere and need some extra padding. I don’t always use it unless I know the iPad is going to get knocked around a bit. The iPad with smart cover just gets slipped in there for extra protection.



    The good:

    -Multipurpose, works as a cover, stand, non-slip backing (when folded back) and actually DOES clean your screen! (I was skeptical)

    -Nice appearance, minimalistic design.

    -High-quality materials. The leather is excellent quality and soft.

    -Stays clean. I did not have the problem with grime that others seem to have, but I also don't take mine into dirty places without extra protection. It only covers the front; you shouldn't do that anyway.


    The not-as-good:

    -The magnet holding the smart cover to the edge is not very strong. You certainly shouldn’t pick up the iPad by just the smart cover. However I had it come off my first iPad several times just as I was folding it back. Interestingly enough, my iPad has been replaced with a new 4th generation model, and this problem is nowhere near as bad. The new magnet strength is about 3/4 of the way between where it was, and where I’d like it to be to be “perfect.” In my opinion, for something like this, I should have to expend some effort to get it off, so that it doesn’t fall off accidentally.

    21 of 25 people found this useful

  • 2.0 out of 5 stars

    Red Polyurethane please!

    • Written by from Ogden

    The only reason why I purchased the leather one, was because I wanted a red one! It's a great cover, however it scratches WAY too easily and it is not durable at all.

    Why apple makes a red urethane smart cover for the mini and not for the regular iPad is ridiculous! I guess I'll have to look elsewhere.

    19 of 33 people found this useful

  • 4.0 out of 5 stars

    Works as described, looks great

    • Written by from Redmond

    I bought this with my iPad 3. It attached precisely as it should. The leather is lovely, and, as stated on the packaging and in the store, the dye can rub off with use. Not that it goes to a natural leather color, but just that some of the red can transfer off of the cover.

    I'd readily buy another if I had an additional iPad to put it on.

    66 of 70 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Don't buy the Smart Leather cover

    • Written by from Raleigh

    Very disappointed my leather Smart iPad cover came apart at the metal rod that was used as the magnet to hold it to the iPad. Less than six months of use. Extremely poor quality. Apple can surely do better. I would give this a 0 rating but the minimum stars is 1. It certainly is not worth a 1 star rating.

    84 of 110 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Works as advertised, aesthetically pleasing.

    • Written by from Brooklyn

    Been using the red leather cover for about 5 months, and I haven't been disappointed so far. It has performed all of its functions (cover/stand/auto-lock&wake) consistently so far, and I like how the leather gets this broken-in kinda look, the way leather should. Some minor remarks are: After a while, the folding sections lose a small bit of their firmness, so you might need a slight bit more precision when folding up the triangle. Also, it seems that the hotter-running 3rd generation iPad causes that gray material on the inside of the hinge to burn a bit over time. It actually left some quite visible marks on my iPad, which I noticed when I removed the cover (something I seldom do), but it was easily cleaned with a damp cloth. The inside of the hinge has a couple of singed spots, but I can live with that. And one other thing, the micro-fiber inside of the cover misses cleaning the spots where the cover folds, so it doesn't do a quite perfect job of passively keeping your screen clean. But this is just a nit-pick, I love the cover.

    89 of 102 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    I like it! Protection without weight and bulk.

    • Written by from ALBUQUERQUE

    I like this case. I had a leather case for my iPad and found it clumsy and also found that it was not holding the iPad in well. Furthermore I had to clean the case with leather cleaner which was annoying (smell). My iPad does not move and the cover shuts and opens well. When it leaves the house I will put it in a neoprene sleeve for added safety, but I am we'll satisfied except for the price which is too high.
    The color is bright, but I will always be able to find it.

    42 of 52 people found this useful