Ive had the case for almost 6 months and it looks horrible!! its broken in places where it shouldnt be and its considered normal wear & tear according to the AT&T store so they wont replace it. But it has kept my phone intact with no damages despite the actual cases tearing apart. So dont purchase if you handle your phone alot
If it's just for protection purposes, it does a really good job. Design wise, at least for iPhone 4 & 4S, the piece of case that goes on the bottom front, right by the charging slot breaks very easy because the plastic part connecting that area is extremely thin, and the rubber wears off fast. After a year of constant use, the phone is intact protection wise, but overall with the case it looks really bad.