• 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Inaccurate in all areas, returned for refund

    • Written by from York

    I bought a Withings Smart Body Analyzer with high hopes for a really well made device with great automation and connectivity. It delivers on all of these but fails horribly on the main reason for buying it - measuring my weight, body fat and pulse.

    Set up was straightforward, but every time I used it, it reported a different weight. And this wasn't hours or days between measures, it was getting on, stepping off and stepping back on again. Weight varied by anything up to several kg on occasion. Moving my body a few degrees forward, back or side to side induced a significant change in reported weight too.

    Body fat measure was, dare I say it, even worse. I'm an average size (my BMI is in the normal range) but the Withings never reported a body fat percentage lower than 50%! I mean, come on, I'm probably a little overweight now but I spent a long time in the gym for many years and I was utterly gobsmacked when I saw the first measurement. I assumed it was an initial error, but repeated measurement over the following week gave variations of 50-59%, and again never consistently. I know body fat measures like this aren't the most reliable, but it's got to be at least in the right order of magnitude to hold any value.

    Pulse measurement was equally bad. Woke up, got out of bed, got onto the scales, Should have been 70ish pulse. Reported anything up to 146 bpm and more. I don't think I saw more than a couple of readings below 100, even after a relaxing evening or sleep.

    I must be the most unhealthy person in existence according to the Withings.

    Anyway, gave up and returned it for a refund as "totally unfit for purpose". The assistant didn't bat an eyelid and just refunded the full amount.

    Sorry Withings, the device looks nice and is well made, but it's as useful as a glass brick for the intended use.

    0 of 1 people found this useful

  • 4.0 out of 5 stars

    Seriously Impressive

    • Written by from Huddersfield

    Ordered from Apple Store and it arrived within 24 hours. Simple to setup and syncs easily with it's own Withings Health app and also MyFitnessPal without any problems.

    Quite expensive but recommended for those who want a lot more from their scales!

    1 of 1 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Top Product!!!!

    • Written by from Hampton Hill

    This product along with My Fitness Pal web service has completely changed my approach to weight loss! It tracks both my weight and my wife's perfectly my only compliant would be that does only ever show right weather. In fact it only shows that it is going to rain, which clearly isn't true :)

    0 of 1 people found this useful

  • 4.0 out of 5 stars

    Good but multi-user setup is horrendous

    • Written by from Newport on Tay

    This is a great product IF you intend to pair it with one iPhone and just have one user, the setup in that case is simple and flawless.

    However, in my case, my partner and I both wanted to use the scales independently, with each of us having our own account on our own iPhone. Succeeding in the setup for this was a total pain. Involving many resets, app deletes, account creations, data deletions and ultimately having to use a combination of iPhone and the both the old and new Withings website to get it setup how we wanted - and how the product promised.

    Great device, but let down by an opaque and immature software setup process.

    4 of 5 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Don't bother, too expansive and isn't accurate

    • Written by from London

    I've had it 24hrs and I'm returning it to Apple. Doesn't work on carpet, despite the 'carpet feet' that it comes with. BPM is way too high - I've had resting BPM of 89, 92 and 99! I'm a hiker in my 30s. When I came home after being at work it needed to be re-synced with my iPhone - 'Setup Failed' 4 times, so I had to delete the scale and go through the installation process again. £129 - maybe for generation 4 is out.

    12 of 13 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Amazing Product

    • Written by from Loughton

    Let’s face it; these are about 3 x the price of the average set of scales. However, in my opinion, they are 10 x as good.
    They give you an average weight so if you haven’t eaten all day, or if you've just had a meal, the graph will not be too skewed.
    Air quality, BMI, and heart rate are also useful tools.

    5 of 7 people found this useful

  • 1.0 out of 5 stars

    Not so smart body analyser...

    • Written by from London

    a good looking bit of kit, simply designed and a great idea to sync up with the iPhone and lifestyle apps, and help you track weight etc. Setting up was a doodle, but after a day or so the scales got confused as to which family member was standing on them. not only that, the weights were extremely variable each time you had a weigh in. we reset, re synced, and eventually re turned. We gave it a chance and wanted it to be as good as it promised, but were sadly disappointed.

    30 of 45 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Awesome piece of kit

    • Written by from Greenhithe

    I bought this to help motivate my weight loss program. Gives great information, much more than really needed. Setup was easy and so far with two months of use has not given my any hassle - so all good.

    25 of 30 people found this useful

  • 5.0 out of 5 stars

    Massively impressed. Setup experience and usage was amazing

    • Written by from New York

    I'm massively impressed by these - the Wifi Setup experience is the best, easiest most straigtforward ever. Took me 3 minutes from opening the parcel to having them up and running - no passwords or rubbish, just perfectly in tune with my iPhone.

    I'm using them with their own app and the ARGUS app and so far its absolutely flawless. I've bought two and another for a friend as a gift already. I wish they would start making wireless printers - I can never get those to work on my network!

    41 of 46 people found this useful